When you’re staying in one of our vacation rentals in Siesta Key, Florida, you’ll have a ton to take advantage of. From the stunning beaches to the unique shopping and the welcoming locals to show you around, there’s a little something for everyone to enjoy.
One of the most exciting and most frustrating parts of vacation is figuring out where to eat. It can be fun to try new and unique cuisine local to the area, but sometimes, the kids have something different in mind than what the adults want.
Luckily, there are several of the best seafood restaurants in Siesta Key just minutes away from our rentals!
Big Water Fish Market
Big Water Fish Market has been a mainstay of the area since November 2011. This establishment is a combination casual restaurant and retail fish market that specializes in fresh Florida seafood. When you walk in, you’ll be greeted by the friendly staff and the casual atmosphere, perfect for a relaxing family dinner.
Their casual dining menu has something for every palate. Start your meal with appetizers like the crab balls or steamed or raw Gulf oysters, then move on to a fish sandwich, fried shrimp plate, fish tacos, or anything in between. The kids can try the seafood too, with selections like a fish fry plate, fried shrimp and fries, and the super grouper fingers. If your kids are a little pickier, they can also choose a cheese quesadilla or chicken fingers and fries. No matter what you select, finish your meal with a slice of Mama’s key lime pie!
The Lobster Pot Restaurant
If you’re looking for New England tradition on the shores of the Florida coast, don’t miss out on The Lobster Pot. The first location was opened in Cape Cod in 1940, and you can still feel the passion more than 80 years later! The Lobster Pot brings in the Florida location and combines it with New England history and Portuguese ancestry to create a one-of-a-kind atmosphere and menu.
The dinner menu at The Lobster Pot features tons of dishes that are made with the freshest ingredients. Start with a kettle of muscles or sweet clam strips, then try a specialty salad or soup. Popular lobster entrees include the baked stuffed lobster duchess and the Maine tail lobster dinner, or you can try other seafood favorites like the Alaskan king crab or sea scallops. For the kids, there are easy to eat seafood options like shrimp and fried fish, as well as land options, pastas, and so much more.
The Cottage
If you’re looking for things to do near Siesta Key, you won’t want to miss out on The Cottage. The tagline says it all: “foodies serving foodies with a passion for craft.” The menu features inventive seasonal cuisine that utilizes produce and meats from sustainable sources. If you’re wanting a place to get that Old Florida feel and experience a meal that is delicious and responsible, this is the place!
Start your meal with mouth-watering seafood options like the calamari or Peruvian ceviche. For your entree, indulge in the truffle filet, Lobster Maki roll, forbidden salmon, or Spanish short ribs. If you’re looking for something a bit lighter, there is a wide selection of sandwiches as well. Complement your meal with a selection from their cocktail menu or sample a red or white wine. With so many menu options, there’s something for everyone in your family, from the most adventurous eater to the pickiest kid’s pallet!
Plan Your Next Visit
This is just a sampling of the Siesta Key seafood dining options available for you and your group. Whether you’re looking for something casual and fun or upscaling fancy, you can find it just minutes away! After you’ve experienced the best dining in Fort Myers Beach, head back to your rental to relax and unwind. Contact us today to learn more about our Siesta Key vacation rentals!
